Posted July 08, 2013

Yasiel Puig, Joaquin Benoit lead candidates for All-Star Game’s Final Vote

All-Star Game
Yasiel Puig and Adrian Gonzalez, Dodgers

Dodgers teammates Yasiel Puig (left) and Adrian Gonzalez are both on the Final Vote ballot. (Thearon W. Henderson/Getty Images)

The All-Star rosters were announced on Saturday, but they are not yet complete. The 34th spot on each roster remains to be filled via the fans’ Final Vote, with five candidates in each league eligible in the voting, which ends Thursday afternoon at 4 p.m. Eastern. Here, then, is a quick look at the candidates in each league ranked by the strength of their candidacies.

National League

1. Yasiel Puig, RF, Dodgers
Stats: .409/.437/.677, 8 HR, 19 RBI, 2.4 bWAR

Who cares if Puig turns out to be the next Jeff Francoeur? The Dodgers’ rookie sensation is a tremendously exciting, talented and thus far productive major league star, and he belongs in the All-Star game. There is a place in the Midsummer Classic for young, exciting, productive talent. Mike Trout and Bryce Harper both made it last year after just two months in the majors, as well they should have. Mark Fidrych made it in 1976, and though he didn’t go on to have the career that his rookie year suggested, that game would have been incomplete without him, and if Francoeur had done what he did as a rookie in 2005 in time for the All-Star Game (he didn’t debut until July 7), he’d have been worthy of a spot as well.

Complete AL and NL All-Star rosters

Puig has made enough of an impact this season that, even if he pancakes from here on out, his first month will be brought up every time a rookie hits the league like a man on fire. His has been a historic performance, and that deserves All-Star recognition.

What’s more, Puig has been so productive in his 32 major league games that he if he does make it to Citi Field, he will do so on his own merits, having posted a wins above replacement total on par or better than his competitors in this vote.

2. Ian Desmond, SS, Nationals
Stats: .281/.327/.502, 15 HR, 49 RBI, 10 SB, 2.5 bWAR

Desmond made the All-Star team last year, so there’s no need to reward him this year for what he did in 2012. What he’s done this year has been impressive enough, particularly compared to the average NL shortstop, who has hit .256/.306/.378 with seven home runs and 33 RBIs. In addition to all of that production at the plate, Desmond has been caught stealing just twice  for an 83 percent success rate on his 10 stolen bases. He’s not an exceptional fielder, but he has been the third most productive shortstop in baseball on the other side of the ball. The catch is that the top two are already on the NL All-Star team. Still, direct your protest votes against Puig here.

3. Freddie Freeman, 1B, Braves
Stats: .306/.382/.462, 9 HR, 56 RBI, 2.3 bWAR

4. Adrian Gonzalez, 1B, Dodgers
Stats: .296/.348/.482, 13 HR, 53 RBI, 1.8 bWAR

I’ll take Freeman’s advantage in getting on-base over Gonzalez’s advantage in slugging, though the fact that Gonzalez plays in a tougher home park makes these two even closer than they appear. Indeed, Gonzalez has a 131 to 129 advantage in OPS+. Still, neither exceeds the standard at first base to the degree that Desmond does at shortstop and there are already three first baseman on the NL roster.

5. Hunter Pence, RF, Giants
Stats: .266/.311/.456, 13 HR, 43 RBI, 13 SB, 2.0 bWAR

The average NL rightfielder this season has hit .271/.333/.445 with 12 home runs and 42 RBIs. Pence plays in a home ballpark that heavily favors pitching, so he has been a bit better than his numbers above, but he’s also a subpar fielder. Outside of being a perfect 13-for-13 in stolen base attempts, he hasn’t really distinguished himself at his position.

American League

1. Joaquin Benoit, RHP, Tigers
Stats: 1.78 ERA, 1.02 WHIP, 11. 2 K/9, 4.40 K/BB, 10% IRS, 2-0, 6 SV, 0 BS, 35 1/3 IP

IRS is inherited runner scoring percentage, which means Benoit has allowed just one of every 10 runners he has inherited from the pitcher before him to score (in fact, those are his exact numbers, he has allowed just one inherited runner to score all season). That rate is the stingiest of this quintet of end-game relievers. Benoit is also the only one in this bunch without a loss or a blown save. In fact, a run hasn’t scored on Benoit’s watch in a Detroit loss all season. You can’t ask more than that from an end-game reliever and Benoit’s other stats are competitive enough that he’s the clear leader here, even if his election would make him the seventh Tiger on the AL roster.

2. Koji Uehara, RHP, Red Sox
Stats: 1.93 ERA, 0.83 WHIP, 12.8 K/9, 6.63 K/BB, IRS 37%, 2-0, 5 SV, 3 BS, 37 1/3 IP

3. Tanner Scheppers, RHP, Rangers
Stats: 1.88 ERA, 1.12 WHIP, 6.1 K/9, 1.71 K/BB, IRS 18%, 5-1, 0 BS, 43 IP

4. David Robertson, RHP, Yankees
Stats: 2.23 ERA, 0.96 WHIP, 11.4 K/9, 3.83 K/BB, IRS 29%, 4-1, 1 BS, 36 1/3 IP

Uehara has the best rate stats of these three but the worst rate of stranding runners and the most combined blown saves and losses. Scheppers is the opposite of that, and Robertson, who was an All-Star in 2011, falls in between despite having the highest ERA and the fewest innings pitched. I suppose that puts Robertson third out of the bunch. Take your pick on Uehara and Scheppers, but I’ll favor Uehara, who has been an elite reliever in the American League since moving into that role in 2010, posting a 2.27 ERA, 0.78 WHIP and 9.44 strikeout-to-walk ratio with 11.6 K/9 and just 1.2 BB/9 in 182 1/3 innings over that span.

5. Steve Delabar, RHP, Blue Jays
Stats: 1.58 ERA, 1.25 WHIP, 12.8 K/9, 2.59 K/BB, IRS 50%, 5-1, 3 BS, 40 IP

Delabar has the eye-catching ERA, but he’s last in this group in WHIP, inherited runner scoring percentage and combined blown saves and losses (and his one loss did not come in a game in which he blew a save). He’s also second-to-last in K/BB ratio having walked a whopping five men per nine innings (which is also the source of his high WHIP). If “Steve Delabar, All-Star” just sounds wrong to you, you’re not alone.

13 comments
stevenclements513
stevenclements513

What a shameless plug for Puig. They didn't even give Freeman a description.

mahi2mahi
mahi2mahi

Let the fans vote on who goes.

Michael10
Michael10

Trout and Harper had each played 63 games at the break last season (more than Harper and starting shortstop Tulowitski have this season) and had more than twice the plate appearances Puig does...

By the way, if you'd bother to scroll down a line or two while prowling the box score for Puig each night, you'd know that Hanley Ramirez has also played 33 games this year -- with better numbers than Puig across the board.

That's right -- Puig is not even the hottest player on his own team...

TylerMorrissey
TylerMorrissey

Pace yourselves, SI. You're gonna get exhausted from all this breathless Puig cheerleading, and there's still more than half a season to go!

I'm excited to see SI's reaction if he doesn't get a spot. Will it be the greatest injustice in sports history, or in in all human history? 

Truth100000
Truth100000

Longoria does not deserve an all star birth.

Truth100000
Truth100000

The Tigers have enough all stars. This is becoming a joke.


The best team in the east has 2 all stars. This is a joke.

Michael10
Michael10

Hey, Cliff. Your mom said stop writing articles about Yaseil Puig long enough to come upstairs and take out the trash...

Both of these managers (who influence the Final Vote ballot) were pretty transparent in the token resistance they provided their candidate -- Puig for Bochy because of league and fanboy pressure, Benoit for Leyland because, hey, seven freakin' Tigers (Benoit also happens to be first alphabetically and has these closest thing to "name recognition" in a field of middle relievers no one has ever heard of).

In the absence of any truly deserving players on the ballot (Longoria, Donaldson, Beltre, Parra, Marte, Martin, Choo, Bruce, etc), I'm throwing my support behind the anti-Puig and Benoit candidates:

1) Hunter Pence -- because the SF political machine might actually get him in and

2) Tanner Scheppers -- because with  a name like "Scheppers," you can't go wrong...

Rob16
Rob16

Longoria is definitely deserving in a normal year, but how many 3B do you need.  He is simply third best this season and that is why he didn't get a spot.  

therednorth1
therednorth1

I don't think you could go wrong with any of those AL relievers.  All five of them have had excellent seasons thus far.

michaelq
michaelq

@therednorth1 I don't think you could go right with any of those AL relievers. None of these guys should be all stars over Longoria, Donaldson, Beltre, Holland, Shields, or Moore. 

hddh
hddh

@therednorth1 I think you could go wrong with all of those AL relievers, especially when a guy like Longoria has yet to be named to the game.